Med Match ForumMed Match Forum

NYP Hosp-Columbia Univ Med Ctr-NY

Columbia

New York, NY

NRMP
1495080R0 / 1495080A0
ACGME
0803521104

Applicant sentiment — from 114 anonymous posts, 2016–2027

5.5 / 10

What anonymous posters said

Several anonymous posts describe the program as generally well regarded and often grouped among other prominent New York City residencies, with a few commenters noting positive interview day experiences. A number of posts also raised open questions about program culture, though opinions were mixed and unresolved.

AI-generated summary of opinions expressed in anonymous, unverified posts. It describes what posters wrote, not verified facts about this program. Based on these 114 posts · Updated Aug 2026 · Contest or respond to this entry · Takedown & right of reply

Match terms
columbiacolumbia dermcolumbia univcolumbia univ med ctrcolumbia universitynyp columbia

Fame & Shame

2026-2027 Derm

1 entry

❌1. Call seems to be the worst out of all the New York schools. Great exposure but the residents seemed tired

2025–2026 Derm

1 entry

❌1. Call seems to be the worst out of all the New York schools. Great exposure but the residents seemed tired

Page 1 of 10

0

Are yall submitting 4 LORs to programs that only specify 3 on their website/ residency explorer?

#6402026-2027 DermSep 20

did 4 for all

Sep 20
0

only did 3

Sep 20
0

did 4 for all x1

Sep 20
0

if program website said "three (3) letters of recommendation" I only sent 3 like GWU

Sep 21
0

only did 3 x1

Sep 21
0

What about Jeff, Columbia, Northwestern? How are you interpreting the 3 letters?

Sep 21
0

did 4 for all x2> only did 3 x1

Sep 24
0
0

did anyone get accpted to columbia?

#1692026-2027 DermMay 10
0

Hey everyone, there’s an opening for a new Cutaneous Oncology Fellowship position at Columbia University. More details posted on @derminterest on Instagram. Anyone eligible and interested can email me directly at om2454@cumc.columbia.edu with your CV!

#862026-2027 DermApr 5

is this for 2026 or 2027?

Apr 5
0

2026

Apr 5
0

New Cutaneous Lymphoma fellowship at Emory University too with Dr. Neda Nikbakht for 2026-2027 - details are in the DIGA fellowship spreadsheet! Email neda.nikbakht@emory.edu with CV and 3 references to apply!

Apr 6
0

New Cutaneous Lymphoma fellowship at Emory University with Dr. Neda Nikbakht for 2026-2027 - details are in the DIGA fellowship spreadsheet! Email neda.nikbakht@emory.edu with CV and 3 references to apply!

Apr 7
0
0

What is the most chill NYC program?

#3892026-2027 DermJun 30

sinai = cornell

Jul 2
0

columbia

Jul 2
0

einstein

Jul 2
0

NYU

Jul 2
0

downstate

Jul 9
0

something to think about is that cornell and columbia have twice as much call as sinai and nyu due to class size

Jul 15
0

cornell & mt sinai

Jul 18
0
0

TEA TIME ANSWERS PLS: Can we talk about the massive exodus/restructuring of high-profile faculty from top institutions over the past 6 months? Like Harvard literally spread its seed all of the eastern seaboard, everybody leaving was being made chair/PD of everything. I'm overexaggerating a bit but still, very surprised, it almost feels like a conspiracy uwu

#7272026-2027 DermSep 26

Also UTSW, columbia

Sep 26
0

like whomst

Sep 26
0

feel like probably related to changes in research funding no?

Sep 27
0

yes Harvard sux nobody go

Sep 27
0

isn't chair of Brown leaving?

Sep 28
0
0

Hey everyone, there’s an opening for a new Cutaneous Oncology Fellowship position at Columbia University. More details posted on @derminterest on Instagram. Anyone eligible and interested can email me directly at om2454@cumc.columbia.edu with your CV!

#36032025–2026 DermApr 5

Reposing since this was deleted - Hey everyone, there’s an opening for a new Cutaneous Oncology Fellowship position at Columbia University. More details posted on @derminterest on Instagram. Anyone eligible and interested can email me directly at om2454@cumc.columbia.edu with your CV!

Apr 6
0

New Cutaneous Lymphoma fellowship at Emory University with Dr. Neda Nikbakht for 2026-2027 - details are in the DIGA fellowship spreadsheet! Email neda.nikbakht@emory.edu with CV and 3 references to apply!

Apr 7
0

where is the DIGA fellowship spreadsheet?

Apr 8
0

Here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1q6rKR0emDDM6twbyT2L3s7_CmsAz8ks8saRUs8Ryl40/edit?gid=0#gid=0

Apr 8
0

Reposting since this was deleted - Hey everyone, there’s an opening for a new Cutaneous Oncology Fellowship position at Columbia University. More details posted on @derminterest on Instagram. Anyone eligible and interested can email me directly at om2454@cumc.columbia.edu with your CV!

Apr 10
0

New Cutaneous Lymphoma fellowship at Emory University with Dr. Neda Nikbakht for 2026-2027 - details are in the DIGA fellowship spreadsheet! Email neda.nikbakht@emory.edu with CV and 3 references to apply!

Apr 10
0

where is the DIGA fellowship spreadsheet?

Apr 10
0

Here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1q6rKR0emDDM6twbyT2L3s7_CmsAz8ks8saRUs8Ryl40/edit?gid=0#gid=0

Apr 10
0

where is the DIGA fellowship spreadsheet? https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1q6rKR0emDDM6twbyT2L3s7_CmsAz8ks8saRUs8Ryl40/edit?gid=0#gid=0 seems pretty out of date tho, not sure how often they update

Apr 13
0
0

Thoughts on UMKC?

#29902025–2026 DermFeb 21

Ranking it higher because St. Louis >>> Columbia, MO

Feb 21
0

it's in kansas city not STL

Feb 21
0
0

Anyone know programs that have good fertility coverage in their insurance :D?

#27862025–2026 DermFeb 21

Whered u interview is the real question for this

Feb 21
0

UCSF has 30k!

Feb 21
0

Penn, Columbia >Mayo has tons of support, UCSD also has robust fertility benefits (I think 20-30k)

Feb 21
0

are fertility benefits mainly egg freezing or do they are include IVF?

Feb 21
0

i think both

Feb 21
0

a handful of programs ive interviewed at have had this. so nice to see!

Feb 21
0

Is there a way to see the fertility specific coverage in a plan or did the programs specifically highlight it as a benefit? would love to know which programs have coverage!

Feb 21
1
0

Does anyone have any insight on what the program at Mizzou is like? everyone there seemed super nice so was just wondering!

#25412025–2026 DermFeb 21

Rotated there - some of the friendliest and most down-to-earth faculty and residents I've ever worked with. Lots of peds derm on the faculty, very welll-rounded curriculum IMO. Columbia is very college town-y so that could be a plus or minus depending on where you are at in life

Feb 21
0

Very kind faculty who want to teach. They will be having residents go to a smaller town 30 min away starting next year but could be a positive if you like that

Feb 21
0
0

UCSF vs Columbia vs UCLA?

#25402025–2026 DermFeb 21

depends on goals but i would definitely rank ucla last and you cant really go wrong with either UCSF or Columbia

Feb 21
0
0

does university of missouri-columbia not do a social or info session??

#24652025–2026 DermFeb 21

Doesn't look like it

Feb 21
0
0

thoughts on columbia v cornell interviews?

#24532025–2026 DermFeb 21

felt like both were pretty equivalent, decent vibes at both

Feb 21
0

didnt interview at columbia but cornell was relatively chill

Feb 21
0

cool thanks

Feb 21
0

other thoughts?

Feb 21
0

cool thanks

Mar 7
0
0

Thoughts on Columbia interviews?

#23362025–2026 DermFeb 21

they were columbian

Feb 21
0

some rooms were good, most were bad lol

Feb 21
1

same with NYU meepl

Feb 21
0

bad how?

Feb 21
0

I thought it was fine/standard idk (for both NYU/columbia)

Feb 21
0

same thought they were both as expected, nothing bad

Feb 21
0

the questions were definitely harder than average but doable I thought... and I totally was expecting cold demeanor but overall they were nice!

Feb 21
0
2

How are Columbia interviews going?

#22882025–2026 DermFeb 21
0

Best program in NYC? All around, not just prestige?

#21332025–2026 DermFeb 21

on a similar note: what's the best program in a major city?

Feb 21
0

Harvard or Penn (if you consider Boston and Philly decent sized cities)

Feb 21
0

NYC Power Rankings: Mount Sinai

Feb 21
0

Columbia = NYU

Feb 21
0

Cornell

Feb 21
0

Albert Einstein

Feb 21
0

Rochester

Feb 21
0

SUNY Downstate = Stony Brook

Feb 21
0

Northwell

Feb 21
0

NYMC

Feb 21
0

St. John's Episcopal

Feb 21
0

St. Barnabas

Feb 21
0

I'd say it goes: NYU

Feb 21
0

Montefiore = SUNY Downstate

Feb 21
0

Sinai = Columbia = Cornell

Feb 21
0

Northwell

Feb 21
0

NYMC. (Rochester and Stony Brook are not NYC, and idk anything about St John's/St. Barnabas)

Feb 21
0

Really?? What makes montefiore above Sinai /columbia?

Feb 21
0

NYU

Feb 21
0

Sinai >= Columbia = Cornell

Feb 21
0

Columbia = NYU

Mar 7
0

Cornell

Mar 7
0

Albert Einstein

Mar 7
0

Rochester

Mar 7
0

SUNY Downstate = Stony Brook

Mar 7
0

Northwell

Mar 7
0

NYMC

Mar 7
0

St. John's Episcopal

Mar 7
0

St. Barnabas

Mar 7
0

Montefiore = SUNY Downstate

Mar 7
0

Sinai = Columbia = Cornell

Mar 7
0

NYMC. (Rochester and Stony Brook are not NYC, and idk anything about St John's/St. Barnabas)

Mar 7
0

Sinai >= Columbia = Cornell

Mar 7
0

Some posts are shown because their comments mention this program.